The belief that all good people are Christians is described here as probably the most common misunderstanding of the gospel in Australia. This paper looks at who holds the view and why, and argues that the gospel itself is at stake, since the idea misunderstands sin, justification and the person and work of Christ.

It advises giving partial, provocative answers that lead towards the gospel, and warns against responses that drift into side issues. It then draws on the teaching of Jesus, passages in Romans, Ephesians 2 and James 2, and verses on why Jesus died. A section on the character of "good" uses illustrations such as swimming to New Zealand, and the paper closes with the illustration of the good pirate and a discussion starter.

Related resources