Most debates among evangelicals come down to authority, this article argues, and in particular the authority of the Bible. It identifies four competing sources of religious authority, the Bible, experience, institution and reason, each tied to a view of what God is like, and notes that everyone draws on a mix of them.

Using examples from the Socinians to the use of statues in worship, it shows how groups can claim the Bible's authority while overriding it. It also warns against shifting disputes from authority to interpretation, using the charismatic debate and 1 Corinthians 12–14 as a case study. The article concludes that the Bible's authority is only maintained if it stands alone, with experience, institution and reason as helpful lights but not supports.

Related resources